Concerned Families of Westchester Newsletter
December 17, 2023
Hello All – Last week President Biden stated that Israel's war on Gaza included "indiscriminate bombing." That is, Israel was committing war crimes. But he has not taken effective action to stop Israel. At the UN last week, 153 nations voted for a ceasefire. Only 10 were opposed, including the US. The US is almost alone in supporting further killing in Gaza, which has claimed the lives of at least 19,000 people, with thousands more buried under the rubble of bombed buildings.
The push back – indeed, international abhorrence – of the refusal of the Biden administration's unwillingness to take effective action to stop Israel's onslaught may be beginning to take effect. Today, according to The New York Times, "Defense Secretary Lloyd J. Austin III will visit Israel and two Persian Gulf nations this week, as Biden administration officials push Israel to end its large-scale ground and air campaign in the Gaza Strip within weeks and transition to a more focused phase in its war against Hamas." Of course, this is less than half-a-loaf: each week of "a few weeks" means Israel will kill another thousand Palestinians, and we must ask if the "transition" to a "more focused phase" of Israel's killing in Gaza will be only less deadly. Also of interest is that the UK and Germany, faithful supporters of the US "no ceasefire" position, echoed the US demand, while going further to call for a "sustainable cesefire."
Are these statements from Israel's main supporters in NATO first steps in bringing Israel's war to an end? If, as we would expect, Israel refuses to comply with NATO orders for a lower-intensity war, will there be any consequences? Of course we cannot know, but even this rhetorical nuance reflects the pressure of millions of voices raised against Israel's war, demanding "ceasefire now." Here are three reasons (there are many more) to keep the pressure on Biden and Congress to support a ceasefire:
The massacre in Gaza is unacceptable.
Whatever right Israel has to defend itself, it does not have the right to commit war crimes or genocide. Some 20,000 Palestinians have been killed, more than one million are homeless, and most hospitals destroyed. Some 400,000 people, suffering in the cold without housing or medical care, have contagious diseases. This slaughter has nothing to do with "self-defense." It has become a massive war crime, and lawyers are splitting hairs on whether it has moved from "ethnic cleansing" to "genocide."
The USA is complicit in Israel's crimes.
Our government gives Israel $3.8 billion in military assistance each year - $10 million per day. We have sent vast amounts of military equipment to Israel, now being used (illegally) to kill civilians. Senator Sanders, in his letter to President Biden last Tuesday, listed many of the weapons and types of ammunition sent to Israel since October 7th, stating "These munitions were provided with the full knowledge they would likely be used in Gaza, a densely populated urban area with a large civilian presence." In doing so, Biden is acting in violation of the Leahy Law, which forbids sending US military aid to military units that have used US weapons to commit war crimes. And, finally, our government has protected Israel from criticism at the UN by using its veto. The views our government as contemptuous of international law and the opinion of the great majority of the world's people.
A ceasefire is needed to free the hostages.
In Israel, the families of those held hostage are demanding a ceasefire and negotiations to free their loved ones. They believe the hostages will be killed unless there is a ceasefire. The tragic killing by Israeli soldiers of three hostages who had escaped their confinement and were trying to "surrender" has renewed calls by thousands of Israelis for a ceasefire and a renewal of negotiations for an exchange of hostages for Palestinians prisoners.
Some Featured Essays on the War on Gaza
We Are No Strangers to Human Suffering, but We've Seen Nothing Like the Siege of Gaza [From international relief organizations]
By Michelle Nunn, et al., New York Times [December 2023]
---- The atrocities committed by Hamas on Oct. 7 were unconscionable and depraved, and the taking and holding of hostages is abhorrent. The calls for their release are urgent and justified. But the right to self-defense does not and cannot require unleashing this humanitarian nightmare on millions of civilians. … Most of our organizations have been operating in Gaza for decades. But we can do nothing remotely adequate to address the level of suffering there without an immediate and complete cease-fire and an end to the siege. The aerial bombardments have rendered our jobs impossible. The withholding of water, fuel, food and other basic goods has created an enormous scale of need that aid alone cannot offset. [Read More] Also of interest on Gaza's genocide – "The Plague as Life: 327,000 Stricken with Infectious Diseases in Gaza," by Juan Cole, Informed Comment [December 15, 2023] [Link]; and (Video) "Please Stop This War Against Us": Gaza Doctor Begs for World's Help as Hunger & Disease Spread," from Democacy Now! [December 11, 2023] [Link].
(Video) Chris Hedges "The Genocide in Gaza"
[FB – This is a powerful, in-depth statement by veteran journalist Chris Hedges, in which he characterizes what is happening now in Gaza as "genocide."] [December 2023] [Link].
Israel's First Unanimous War
By Gideon Levy, Haaretz [Israel] [December 13, 2023]
---- We've never before had a war like this, a war of complete consensus, a war of total silence, a war of blind support; a war without objection, without protest, without refusal to serve, without opposition, neither in the beginning or in the middle. A unanimous war, with wall-to-wall approval – excluding the Arab citizens of the state, who have been prohibited from objecting – and without question marks or even any doubts. Is a war that has already killed nearly 20,000 people, the vast majority of them innocent civilians, and destroyed nearly all the homes and the lives of the residents of the Gaza Strip, the most just war in the history of Israel? … As far as Israelis are concerned, it's possible to keep this war going forever, to kill all the inhabitants of the Gaza Strip and destroy it entirely, for good. The most moral, the most just. ]Read More] In Haaretz today, Levy writes: "In Israel, 20,000 Gazans Are Responsible for Their Own Deaths. I've Never Been So Ashamed," [Link].
(Video) Israel is choosing 'apartheid' or 'ethnic cleansing'
From Aljazeera ("The Bottom Line") [December 16, 2023]
---- US political scientist John Mearsheimer on Israel's 'punishment campaign' against the civilian population in Palestine. … Israel has gone far beyond "going after Hamas" in the first 10 weeks of its war on Gaza, according to one of the United States' leading political scientists, John Mearsheimer. He tells host Steve Clemons that murdering hundreds of civilians daily and starving the rest is a "punishment campaign" and "should be unacceptable to decent people all over the world." [See the Program].
A Gazan Dilemma: When Saving Your Life Is Expulsion by Israel
By Amira Hass, Haaretz [Israel] [December 11, 2023]
---- In Ramallah, public figures have been expressing their admiration for Gazans' steadfastness in the face of semiofficially declared Israeli plans to expel them from the enclave and resettle them in Egypt. But the praise is belied by the Gazans themselves, who talk about how badly they would like to leave and escape death, injury, hunger, thirst and humiliation. "We remain steadfast in spite of ourselves," they say. [Read More] For ethnic cleansing elsewhere in Israel, watch (Video) "How Israeli Settler Violence Forces Palestinians To Flee Their Homes," from Aljazeera [December 15, 2023] [Link].
News Notes
Growing support in Congress for ceasefire, negotiations - The number of congressional supporters for a ceasefire in Gaza has grown from 14 (including Rep. Jamaal Bowman) to 62, including 4 Senators, according to the Working Families Ceasefire-Tracker. Peace Action of New York State (PANYS – CFOW is an affiliate) is targeting Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, who is opposed to a ceasefire. If you support a ceasefire and more humanitarian aid for Gaza, please call Sen. Gillibrand at 202) 224-4451. Tell her (or the phone answerer or the machine) your name, where you live, and what you want. Thanks!
Boycotts and protests – how are people around the world defying Israel?
From Aljazeera [December 15, 2023]
---- From Jakarta to San Francisco, hundreds of thousands of people have taken to the streets over the past two months to protest Israel's ongoing assault on Gaza. According to the Armed Conflict Location & Events Data Project, a nongovernmental organisation specialising in conflict data collection, from October 7 to November 24, there were at least 7,283 pro-Palestine protests that took place in more than 118 countries and territories. Many more have chosen to express their condemnation using their purchasing power, opting to boycott products and services that support Israel, in turn fueling the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement that was set up in 2005 by a coalition of Palestinian civil society groups. [Read More]
CFOW Nuts & Bolts
Please consider getting involved with Concerned Families of Westchester. Weather permitting we meet for a protest/rally each Saturday in Hastings, at 12 noon at the VFW Plaza (Warburton and Spring St.) A "Black Lives Matter/Say Their Names" vigil is held in Yonkers on Monday from 5:30 to 6:00 pm at the intersection of Warburton Ave. and Odell. Our newsletter is archived at https://cfow.blogspot.com/; and news of interest and coming events is posted on our CFOW Facebook page. Another Facebook page focuses on the climate crisis. If you would like to join one of our Zoom meetings, each Tuesday and Thursday at noon, please send a return email for the link. If you would like to support our work by making a contribution, please send your check to CFOW, PO Box 364, Hastings-on-Hudson, NY 10706. Thanks!
Rewards!
Given the state of the news/world, this week's Rewards for stalwart newsletter readers are a small attempt to lift spirits. I hope you will enjoy the John and Yoko holiday classic, "Happy Xmas (War is Over." Today's newsletter was written with assistance from the music of New Orleans ensemble Tuba Skinny. Here is one I like: "Over in the Gloryland." Tuba Skinny has many more songs on-line. Enjoy!
Best wishes,
Frank Brodhead
For CFOW
The CFOW Weekly Reader
The War on Gaza
(Video) "Politics of Memory": Masha Gessen's Hannah Arendt Prize Postponed for Comparing Gaza to Warsaw Ghetto
From Democracy Now! [December 15, 2023]
---- We speak with the acclaimed Russian American writer Masha Gessen, whose latest article for The New Yorker looks at the politics of Holocaust commemoration in Europe. Gessen was scheduled to receive the prestigious Hannah Arendt Prize in Germany on December 15, but the ceremony was postponed after some award sponsors withdrew support over Gessen's comparison in the article of Gaza to the Warsaw Ghetto. A smaller award ceremony is set for Saturday. Gessen says Germany's culture of learning about and atoning for the sins of the Nazi regime has morphed into steadfast support for the state of Israel despite its actions, while banning most forms of pro-Palestinian solidarity as part of a flawed effort to fight antisemitism. The cornerstone of this form of "memory politics" is that "you can't compare the Holocaust to anything," says Gessen. "My argument is that in order to learn from history, we have to compare." [See the Program]. Of interest is the extraordinary essay by Gessen in the New Yorker, "In The Shadow of the Holocaust," [December 9, 2023] [Link]. Also of interest is this short documentary video, "Palestine: Banned in Berlin," Aljazeera [Link].
(Video) Jeremy Scahill: Gaza "Scorched-Earth Campaign" Is a "Joint U.S.-Israeli Operation"
From Democracy Now! [December 14, 2023]
---- We discuss President Joe Biden's "full support for a scorched-earth campaign" in Gaza with The Intercept's Jeremy Scahill, who says the U.S. is providing "political cover and rushing weapons there and giving support to the most pernicious lies that Israel [is] telling." Despite the Biden administration's recent assertions that it is helping to restrain Israel, Israel's military and intelligence operation is significantly propped up by resources from the United States State and Defense departments, explains Scahill. "This is a joint U.S. operation militarily and politically." Meanwhile, he says, Biden continues to repeat debunked falsehoods about pictures of beheaded babies from the October 7 Hamas attack. [See the Program]. Also of interest by Jeremy Scahill, "This Is Not a War Against Hamas," The Intercept [December 11, 2023] [Link].
From Gaza to Jenin, we must resist Israel's cultural genocide
By Zoe Lafferty, New Arab [December 14, 2023]
---- The Israeli occupation forces (IOF) invasion in Jenin Refugee Camp had been ongoing for 30hrs when they entered The Freedom Theatre just past 9am. Ransacking the offices and knocking down a wall, they then shot from inside the building. Next, the IOF went to the homes of artistic director Ahmed Tobasi and producer Mustafa Sheta, blindfolding, handcuffing and taking them away. Hours later they severely beat recently graduated acting student Jamal Abu Joas and kidnapped him as well. … As the genocide continues in Gaza and invasions in Jenin Camp happen daily, it is hard to find the line between devastation and hope, loss and defiance, reality and optimism. What is clear is that Palestinians have managed to unite those around the world of different ages, backgrounds, cultures and religions, to not only stand up for Palestinian rights and voices, but also our own. [Read More] Also of interest is this interview with the director of the Freedom Theater, "Israel Raids Freedom Theatre in Jenin Refugee Camp; Director Speaks Out After Being Jailed & Beaten," from Democracy Now! [December 15, 2023] [Link]. Creative people are pushing back everywhere. Read "More Than 2,000 Poets Boycott The Poetry Foundation for Censoring Pro-Palestine Voices," by Summer Farah, Palestine Studies [
[December 13, 2023] [Link]. Some additional articles re: the War on Gaza – "'The hostages weren't our top priority': How Israel's bombing frenzy endangered captives in Gaza," by Yuval Abraham, +972 Magazine [December 17, 2023] [Link]; "Fact or fiction: Is Israel really rounding up 'Hamas fighters'?: by Marc Owen Jones, Aljazeera [December 10, 2023] [Link]; and "'Tell me how this ends' – Gaza Edition," by Juan Cole, Informed Comment [December 16, 2023] [Link].
The Climate Crisis
What No One at COP28 Wanted to Say Out Loud: Prepare for 1.5 Degrees
By David Wallace-Wells, New York Times [December 16, 2023]
---- It only took 28 years. When Sultan Ahmed Al Jaber banged his gavel on the resolution text of COP28 in Dubai on Wednesday, it marked what has been widely called a historic achievement: the first time nearly every country on Earth agreed that oil and gas play a role in driving global warming, and the first time they nodded toward the need for a fossil fuel drawdown. … The question isn't about whether there will be a transition, but how fast, global and thorough it will be. The answer is: not fast or global or thorough enough yet, at least on the current trajectories, which COP28 effectively affirmed. [Read More] For additional views on COP28 – "Top Ten Reasons to Dismiss the Conference of Polluters 28," by Patrick Bond and Desmond D'Sa, ZNet [December 15, 2023] [Link]; and (Video) "Phase Down, Not Phase Out: COP28 Deal on Fossil Fuels Disappoints Activists & Vulnerable States," from Democracy Now! [December 13, 2023] [Link].
Civil Liberties/"The War on Terror"
Terrorism Investigations on Campus and the New McCarthyism
By Anthony O'Rourke and Wadie E. Said, Dissent Magazine [December 8, 2023]
---- In the 1960s, the FBI's counterintelligence program (COINTELPRO) routinely infiltrated campus antiwar and civil rights groups, investigating thousands of students with the aim of discrediting their activism and destroying their career prospects. After a Senate committee led by Frank Church exposed this practice, the FBI disavowed it and applied a heightened standard for initiating investigations at universities. There is reason to believe, however, that federal law enforcement is facing pressure to relax its self-restraint and investigate pro-Palestinian student activists.[Read More] Also of interest – "The bipartisan attack on Palestine solidarity is higher than ever," from Mondoweiss [Link].
The News Media
It's Time for Gaza's Journalists to Be Treated Like the Heroes They Are
By Nadia Taha, The Nation [December 12, 2023]
---- The fact that the international journalists who briefly enter the Gaza Strip to report must assent to Israeli government censorship makes the work of Palestinian journalists especially valuable as stringers and freelancers for international news outlets. Working through a humanitarian crisis, these journalists demonstrate the remarkable tenacity and adaptability required of any war reporter, but with the added complication that they live, along with their families, in the war zone. The death toll among journalists shows the risks to Palestinians in particular. Of the 63 journalists [now 92] killed since October 7, all but seven are Palestinians. [Read More] Also of interest – Two articles from FAIR (Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting) – "NYT Misrepresents Zionism's Opponents as Anti-Jewish Bigots," by Jim Naureckas, FAIR [Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting] [December 15, 2023] [Link]; and "NYT Amplifies Outrage Over Imaginary Calls for Genocide," by Ari Paul, FAIR [Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting] [December 12, 2023] [Link].
Our History
The Rise and Rollout of AOC's Green New Deal
By Ryan Grim, The Intercept [December 8 2023]
---- The "green dream" had started as a Google Doc put out by Sunrise, AOC, and the other groups behind the march on Pelosi's office, and while the idea of a Green New Deal took off, the document itself came in for immediate criticism, both from the AFL-CIO, which warned that it would cost union jobs in the fossil fuel and pipeline industries, and from climate justice activists, who thought it didn't go far enough in redressing the systemically racist impacts of climate change and pollution. Moving from dreamland to Google Doc to a congressional resolution (which is significantly short of legislation) required much more compromise than might be expected in an aspirational document. [Read More] For more from Ryan Grim's new book on "The Squad," here is (Podcast) "The Squad," Part 3: The Last Gaza War, from The Intercept [December 15 2023] [Link].
Prequel: An American Fight Against Fascism
By Joan M. Burda, NY Journal of Books
[FB – This is a review of Rachel Maddow's new book, Prequel.]
---- It isn't often that a nonfiction book comes along that is by turns gripping, frightening, and enlightening. Prequel, however, is one of those books. In Prequel Rachel Maddow presents a thoroughly researched historical perspective of the rise of U.S. based fascism. What is particularly disconcerting is how the language used by the apologists for Naziism and fascism in the 1930s is again being heard in the country in 2023. [Read More] Also of interest re: the US "dark ages": "Blacklisted Communist Writer Albert Maltz's Last Novel Will Finally Be Published in the US," by Taylor Dorrell, Jacobin [November 2023] [Link[.